The 80/20 of Cold Email: Why 80% of Your Success Comes from the List (Not the Copy)

The 80/20 of Cold Email: Why 80% of Your Success Comes from the List (Not the Copy)

When people talk about cold email, most focus on the subject line, the CTA or some clever personalization hack

Written by

Hashir Khurram

Published on

October 6, 2025

13

min

But let me break something down for you:

  • A grade copy + C grade list means noise

  • C grade copy + A grade list means pipeline

Thats the brutal truth And heres how to fix it

Why List Quality is 80% of the Game

Lets say you’re sending emails to:

  • The wrong job titles

  • The wrong industries

  • People who do not have buying power

No matter how slick your copy is, you will end up with:

  • Crickets

  • Spam complaints

  • Wasted sending volume

Now flip that, Target:

  • The right decision makers

  • At the right companies

  • With buying intent, pain or momentum

Suddenly, even a simple email like:

  • “Hey John quick one, Are you still the right person to speak with about [X]?”

gets replies

How to Build That Kind of List (Without Guessing)

Heres the workflow we use:

  1. Start with Company Logic

  • “Companies using Shopify + Recharge”

  • “AI startups that raised Seed rounds in 2024”

  • “Roofers in Texas with 100+ Google reviews”

  1. Scrape with Scrapeamax

  • Use Crunchbase, BuiltWith, GMB, BBB, Clutch and more

  • We get the actual company data, not people first

  1. Enrich with Clay

  • Use the company data to pull verified contacts

  • Filter by seniority, titles, tech stack, hiring signals

  1. Validate with MillionVerifier

  • Clean and confirm emails to protect deliverability

  • 5. Send with Smartlead

  • Rotate inboxes, sequence smartly and track replies

What You Avoid with This Stack

  • Generic Apollo/SalesNav scraping

  • High bounce rates and spam traps

  • Lists that every other agency is hitting

  • Wasting time “guessing” whos the right person

What You Gain Instead

  • Hyper relevant company targeting

  • Verified, fresh decision maker data

  • Faster replies with fewer follow ups

  • A system you can repeat across verticals

Real World Example

We scraped 213 SaaS companies using Calendly + Stripe from BuiltWith, enriched via Clay and validated

Within 3 days: 38 replies, 11 demos, 4 closed deals

And the copy was not fancy, Just relevant

Want to Try It For Free?

If your business is doing $250k+/year and you are not in adult/crypto/gambling we will build your first list for free

Book a Call + Get Slack Access to Scrapeamax

https://calendly.com/hashir-khurram/scrapeamax-unlimited-lead-lists

You will see how cold email works when the list actually deserves a reply

Scrape smarter, Close faster, Stop guessing

The Scrapeamax Team

Hashir Khurram

🏆 Winner SaaS Bootstrapper of the year 2024 Award by Tekpon | Growing Expandi towards $10M ARR | Prioritizing health -9% body fat year-round 🏋️‍♂️ | Sharing Real Stories in Public


You’ve made it all the way down here, take the final step -

You’ve made it all the way down here, take the final step -