Why Most Lead Lists Are Garbage And How to Fix It with Context First Prospecting

Why Most Lead Lists Are Garbage And How to Fix It with Context First Prospecting

Ever bought a list of leads and thought:

Written by

Hashir Khurram

Published on

October 31, 2025

13

min

“Wow. These contacts are either outdated, irrelevant, or totally random.”

You are not alone.

Most “lead databases” start by giving you a bunch of people but no context:

  • Who they work for is not qualified

  • What the company does is not aligned

  • Or worse: you are missing the timing signal entirely

Let’s fix that.

The Problem With People First List Building

Here’s the traditional model:

  1. Pick a job title (e.g. “Head of Marketing”)

  2. Pick a few filters like industry, location, revenue

  3. Download a list

Sounds fine, right?

But:

  • These platforms recycle the same names over and over

  • Filters are often vague or poorly tagged

  • You have no idea what’s happening inside the company

You might email a VP of Marketing at a company that just got acquired or a founder at a startup that pivoted 8 months ago.

It’s lazy. And it’s noisy.

What Actually Works: Context First Prospecting

Instead of starting with people, start with the company context.

Ask:

  • Are they using a specific tech stack? (Stripe, HubSpot, Gorgias?)

  • Are they hiring for roles related to your offer?

  • Are they in expansion mode?

  • Did they just raise a round?

  • Are they in a high intent directory with strong reviews?

Once you have that, then find the right person inside.

And when you do that, your reply rate explodes.

Scrapeamax: Built for Context First Targeting

Scrapeamax was designed to make this style of prospecting effortless.

Here’s what we do differently:

- You tell us the company level logic

- We scrape verified businesses from 10+ premium sources:

  • Google Maps

  • BuiltWith

  • Latka

  • Clutch

  • Store Leads

  • Agency Vista

  • GoodFirms

  • Crunchbase

  • Trustpilot

  • BBB

- You get back clean, enriched CSVs

- You plug into Clay, Findymail, Smartlead, whatever stack you use

- You go live , same day

No subscriptions. No login limits. No rows per month BS.

Just fast, verified, context first lead lists that actually get replies.

Examples of Context That Converts

  • “Dentists in Florida with >50 Google reviews”

  • “SaaS companies using HubSpot + Calendly + Stripe”

  • “Home service businesses in Texas with BBB accreditation”

  • “DTC brands using Shopify + Recharge”

  • “AI startups who raised Series A in past 6 months”

You cannot get this on Apollo But you can get it with Scrapeamax, usually in under 3 hours.

Want to Try It Free?

We will give you your first list on the house.

- No contracts

- No scraping tools required

- Just one Slack message means lead list in your inbox

Book a Call + Get Access

If you are serious about cold email, start serious about the list.

And that starts with context, not contacts.

Hashir Khurram

🏆 Winner SaaS Bootstrapper of the year 2024 Award by Tekpon | Growing Expandi towards $10M ARR | Prioritizing health -9% body fat year-round 🏋️‍♂️ | Sharing Real Stories in Public


You’ve made it all the way down here, take the final step -

You’ve made it all the way down here, take the final step -